In Société Générale (C-241/25), the Grand Chamber of the CJEU held on 17 November 2026 that Article 63 TFEU precludes a tax authority from systematically requiring a loss-making non-resident company to prove its loss by recalculating its taxable result under the source state’s rules.
The case concerned Swedish withholding tax on dividends received in 2012 by a French company which, like its consolidated group, reported substantial French tax losses. The Court went further than the Advocate General on comparability: a resident and a non-resident company are comparable when each company’s result is determined under the rules of its own state of residence, because that result reflects its ability to pay.
For taxable institutional investors holding cross-border equities, the issue is practical as well as legal: relief recognised under Sofina should become easier to obtain, as source states may no longer insist on a separate domestic-law loss calculation as a matter of course. Even where relief is available, it may represent a deferral rather than a permanent tax saving if the investor later returns to profitability. The case is therefore about both access to relief and its potential economic value.
Because the Court based its evidentiary standard on case law concerning investment and pension funds, the judgment is also relevant to tax-exempt investors, whose reclaims frequently turn on evidentiary requirements.
The dispute
Société Générale SA, the French parent of a consolidated tax group, received Swedish-source dividends in 2012 on which SEK 4,922,895 of withholding tax was levied. It sought a refund, arguing that a comparable loss-making Swedish company would not have paid corporate income tax on those dividends in that year.
In submissions to the Swedish courts, Société Générale reported a 2012 French tax loss of EUR 1,836,366,589 and a consolidated group loss of EUR 979,403,542. It was undisputed that both reported substantial French tax losses and that no recalculation under Swedish tax law had been carried out. The disagreement was about the method of proving eligibility for relief, not whether the French returns showed losses.
The Administrative Court in Falun dismissed the claim because comparability had not been established; the Administrative Court of Appeal in Sundsvall upheld that outcome. On appeal, Sweden’s Supreme Administrative Court referred three questions to the CJEU in March 2025.
The cost of the required calculation was central to the dispute. Société Générale argued that reconstructing the taxable results of its approximately 250-member French group under Swedish rules would probably cost more than the refund itself.
The Swedish rules and the questions referred
Sweden generally imposes 30% dividend withholding tax on non-resident legal persons, reduced in this case by the Sweden–France treaty to a maximum of 15%. Resident companies instead include taxable dividends in their corporate income tax calculation; a company with an overall tax loss pays no corporate tax on those dividends in that year. The difference can amount to a cash-flow disadvantage or, if profitability never returns, a definitive one.
Following Sofina, Sweden introduced deferral rules for certain loss-making EU companies from 1 January 2020; these did not apply to the 2012 dividends in dispute. They require losses to be calculated under Swedish tax legislation, taking account of group results where relevant. As with a resident company, whose taxable dividends reduce its loss carryforward and so bring forward tax once it returns to profit, the relief is often one of timing, although the timing and amount of any later tax may differ between the two. The non-resident’s deferred withholding tax also remains a separately identifiable liability: a deferral is renewed only for a following tax year in which there is sufficient deferral headroom, and the deferred amount may become payable when the company reports a positive result. The mechanism therefore does not necessarily produce a permanent refund, although the legislative history indicates that a deferral should become definitive if the company ceases trading without returning to profit.
The referring court asked whether Article 63 TFEU allows Sweden (i) to insist on a Swedish-law recalculation of a foreign company’s losses; (ii) to take account of the entire foreign consolidated group; and (iii) to do so despite differences between the Swedish and French group taxation systems. The first question is the central issue; the other two concern which entity’s losses should count.
The EU-law framework
Sofina (C-575/17)
The CJEU held that France restricted the free movement of capital by imposing immediate withholding tax on dividends received by loss-making Belgian companies while allowing comparable resident companies to defer taxation. The Court accepted that the source state may require evidence of losses, but did not specify whether those losses must be recalculated under source-state tax rules.
Credit Suisse Securities (Europe) (C-601/23)
The Court reaffirmed the Sofina principle in a Spanish withholding tax dispute and emphasised that less favourable treatment must be assessed separately for each financial year. This matters for institutional investors that are profitable over time but incur losses in particular years. The Court also indicated that the dividends could be taxed once the non-resident returned to profitability, as for a resident company, subject to verification by the national court. The Sofina principle therefore does not necessarily confer a permanent exemption, although the timing and amount of any later tax depend on national rules.
Futura Participations and Singer (C-250/95)
This judgment cuts both ways. In a freedom-of-establishment dispute concerning a Luxembourg branch, the Court recognised territorial limits on deductible losses, but also rejected an unnecessarily exclusive method of proving them. Germany invokes its territoriality reasoning in Société Générale; the counterargument is that dividend taxation of an investor is different from attributing branch losses to a source state.
ACC Silicones (C-572/20)
The Court held that additional conditions imposed on non-resident companies seeking dividend withholding tax refunds can themselves restrict capital movements. It reinforces the point that the practical conditions of relief, not just the headline tax treatment, matter under Article 63.
Together, these judgments establish the right to equivalent treatment, recognise a legitimate need for verification and leave open how demanding the verification process may be. A loss recognised under French law need not be identical to a loss under Swedish law; the question is whether requiring a complete Swedish-law reconstruction is a proportionate response to that difference.
The Advocate General’s opinion
In his opinion of 18 June 2026, Advocate General Jean Richard de la Tour proposed that Article 63 TFEU precludes the Swedish-law recalculation requirement. The case was allocated to the Grand Chamber following a request by Germany, which, supported by Spain, argued that territoriality limits comparability between resident and non-resident companies.
Comparability
Germany relied in part on Futura Participations and Marks & Spencer to argue that source-state relief need only account for expenses or losses linked to source-state income. The Advocate General distinguished those cases: Société Générale received Swedish dividends as an investor, rather than carrying on an activity in Sweden whose profits and losses had to be allocated territorially. In his view, requiring identical domestic-law calculations goes beyond what objective comparability demands in this context.
Evidence and proportionality
The Advocate General accepted that Sweden may require reliable proof of a loss, but not necessarily one prescribed method of proof. French tax documents and further supporting information could be verified, including through EU administrative cooperation. Even Skatteverket acknowledged in the national proceedings that it was doubtful whether the foreign result must follow Swedish substantive rules, although it maintained that the claimant bore the burden of proof. Requiring full recalculations in multiple source states could make relatively modest refunds uneconomic.
Justifications
The Advocate General rejected balanced allocation of taxing powers because the disputed calculation affects the timing of taxation, not Sweden’s tax base; fiscal cohesion because there was no corresponding specific levy; and anti-avoidance because an automatic recalculation requirement was not targeted at fraud or artificial arrangements.
The group issue
Because both Société Générale and its consolidated group reported losses, the Advocate General regarded the second and third questions as hypothetical. He nevertheless suggested that the dividend recipient’s own result should ordinarily govern, absent fraud. As discussed below, the Court did not adopt that view in terms.
The Court’s decision
Sitting as a Grand Chamber, the Court answered the three questions together. Article 63 TFEU precludes a tax authority practice of requiring a non-resident company that belongs to a consolidated group to prove its loss by systematically recalculating its taxable result under the source state’s rules.
Restriction
Relying on Santander Renta Variable España Pensiones (C-525/24), the Court confirmed that a restriction can arise from the evidence a non-resident must produce, not only from the substantive conditions for relief. A systematic recalculation is an additional administrative burden borne only by non-residents, which is liable to deter investment in the source state.
Comparability
The Court’s starting point was that Swedish law taxed dividends on shareholdings representing less than 10% of the distributing company’s capital whether they were paid to resident or non-resident companies, so that the two categories were comparable. It then went beyond the Advocate General. Relief for loss-making companies generally reflects their reduced ability to pay, and a resident and a non-resident company are in the same situation when each company’s result is determined under the rules of its own state of residence. A recalculation under source-state rules describes a hypothetical situation; differences between national systems may cut either way and follow from the absence of harmonisation. The Court also rejected Germany’s and Spain’s challenge to the comparability reasoning in Sofina and Credit Suisse Securities: territoriality is a matter of justification rather than comparability, and Miljoen concerns the tax base rather than the timing of payment.
Justifications and evidence
Balanced allocation of taxing powers and fiscal cohesion were rejected. Combating fraud and tax avoidance is a legitimate objective, and a source state may require the evidence reasonably needed to establish that the company is genuinely loss-making and that the conditions for relief were not created artificially, verified where necessary through mutual assistance. A systematic recalculation, however, rests on a generalised presumption of fraud rather than on indications of abuse, and its considerable burden makes relief excessively difficult to obtain. A source state cannot require documents that conform in every respect to its own requirements where other documents allow it to verify clearly and precisely that the conditions are met.
The group issue and the limits of the ruling
A systematic recalculation of the whole consolidated group is disproportionate a fortiori, and Sweden’s intra-group transfer rules make no difference. Marks & Spencer was distinguished because the case concerns the timing of source-state taxation, not the deduction of foreign losses. The Court did not, however, adopt the Advocate General’s view that the recipient’s own result should ordinarily govern, and it expressly left aside capital movements involving third countries. What fails is a systematic requirement that excludes alternative evidence; targeted requests where there are indications of abuse may remain permissible.
Taxology’s view: implications for investors and WHT reclaims
For insurers, banks and other taxable investors with cross-border equity portfolios, the judgment removes a potentially prohibitive obstacle to Sofina relief. Source states can no longer systematically require foreign results to be recalculated under their own rules, because the result determined under the investor’s own residence-state rules is what reflects its ability to pay. Loss-year claims that were uneconomic in some markets may now be worth pursuing, and claims rejected for want of a source-state calculation should be reviewed, subject to limitation periods. Sweden’s current deferral rules, and similar post-Sofina mechanisms elsewhere, are also called into question.
Relief may be a deferral. Where a source state operates a deferral mechanism, tax relieved in a loss-making year may become payable once the investor returns to profit, so the benefit may be one of timing. That can still be substantial: Société Générale stated that its French tax group had some EUR 10.6 billion of losses carried forward.
Relevance for tax-exempt investors. The Court built its evidentiary standard on Köln-Aktienfonds Deka (C-156/17) and Santander Renta Variable España Pensiones (C-525/24), a pension fund case: a source state cannot insist on documents that conform in every respect to its own requirements where other evidence allows clear and precise verification. Pension funds facing documentation demands designed for resident entities can now rely on a Grand Chamber judgment applying that standard.
Open questions. The Court did not decide whether a source state may take a consolidated group’s result into account at all, and it expressly left open the position of non-EU claimants, where the absence of EU mutual assistance may affect the proportionality assessment. Source states also remain entitled to verify claims and to request more evidence where there are indications of abuse.
Taxology’s assessment
Verification remains legitimate, but proof requirements may no longer become an obstacle to exercising the right itself. Investors should review both their pending and rejected claims and the evidentiary demands that source states impose on them.
Topics